9-2-2000 Amerikid (1) (Exeland, WI)
-Defeated Shinobi to become the first champion.
4-28-2001 El Supremo (1) (Ladysmith, WI)
7-7-2001 Tim Storm (1) (Bruce, WI)
-Defeated El Supremo and Shinobi in a three-way match.
9-1-2001 Red Lightning (Exeland, WI)
9-3-2001 "Superstar" Steve Stardom (1) (Bruce, WI)
9-22-2001 Shinobi (1) (Ingram, WI)
9-22-2001 Amerikid (2) (Ingram, WI)
4-13-2002 El Supremo (2) (Eleva, WI)
5-4-2002 Tim Storm (2) (Eau Claire, WI)
-Tim Storm was stripped of the title for failure to defend.
6-22-2002 "Superstar" Steve Stardom (2) (Cornell, WI)
-Defeated Mayhem and Stat IC in a three-way match for the vacant title.
8-4-2002 Mayhem (Ingram, WI)
-Mayhem was stripped of the title after missing three consecutive title defenses.
9-1-2002 El Vato (Weyerhauser, WI)
-Defeated Shinobi for the vacant title.
-El Vato was stripped for missing two mandatory title defenses.
3-8-2003 Shinobi (2) (Stratford, WI)
-Defeated Major Chaos, Trey and Cameron Steele in a four-way match for the vacant title.
6-1-2003 J-Real (Ladysmith, WI)
8-7-2003 Adrian Serrano (Ladysmith, WI)
2-8-2004 Ace Spade (Holcombe, WI)
-Ace Spade surrendered the title after suffering a knee injury.
5-15-2004 Sledge (Spooner, WI)
-Defeated Cameron Steele for the vacant title.
8-7-2004 Venom (Rib Lake, WI)