6-13-1992 The Canadian Patriot (Amherstburg, ON)
-Defeated Bobby Clancy in a tournament final to crown the first BCW Can-Am Champion.
3-29-1993 Denny Kass (Warren, ON)
5-29-1993 Mickey Doyle (1) (LaSalle, ON)
7-4-1993 Rock Stevens (Livonia, MI)
8-14-1993 Scott D'Amore (1) (Noelville, ON)
-Defeated Otis Apollo for the vacant title.
5-6-1994 Jack Steel (North Bay, ON)
5-7-1994 Scott D'Amore (2) (Noelville, ON)
6-17-1994 Mickey Doyle (2) (Wallaceburg, ON)
3-10-1995 Scott D'Amore (3) (Oldcastle, ON)
4-21-1995 Bruiser Bedlam (LaSalle, ON)
6-23-1995 Scott D'Amore (4) (LaSalle, ON)
5-17-2000 Sabu (London, ON)
3-7-2001 Tommy Dreamer (Oldcastle, ON)
-Defeated Scott D'Amore and Rhino in a three-way match for the vacant title.
4-18-2001 Scott D'Amore (5) (Oldcastle, ON)
4-18-2001 Mikey Whipwreck (Oldcastle, ON)
11-27-2001 Johnny Swinger (Oldcastle, ON)
3-6-2003 D'Lo Brown (Oldcastle, ON)
-D'Lo Brown defeated Gangrel for the MXPW Heavyweight Title on 4-17-2003. This unified the MXPW Heavyweight and BCW Can-Am titles into the MXPW Unified Heavyweight Title.